A session I presented at last year's Sakai Summer Institute about blogging in the classroom:
Last year, when I decided to have my students do a blogging project
, I looked at several different blogging platforms and was incredibly, insanely, pulling-my-hair-out, dancing-around-in-frustration-like-Ted-Knight-in-CaddyShack
aggravated at how difficult it was to get a blog to do what I wanted to.
In the end, I decided to go with EduBlogs
, largely because it let me moderate comments from students, but I have to admit, I wasn't thrilled with it. It seemed clumsy, difficult to design with and... well, ...
You know what? That really doesn't matter, because EduBlogs
has redeemed itself with a semi-new feature - I can edit blog comments before posting them.
No, seriously - this is a huge deal for me.
In order to protect student privacy, my policy is that when students post their blogs as comments, they identify themselves with only their first name and last initial. Invariably, some students forget and use their whole name. Last year, when that happened, I'd have to copy their comment, paste it into a comment myself, remove the last name, and then repost it with a short message explaining why their assignment was posted under my name.
With the Edit Comments function, I can remove anything, replace school-inappropriate language with asterixes (asterices?), etc.. on the fly. Also, I can comment on each assignment, right there, attached to their comment and give them semi-instant feedback. Later on, when I'm grading the assignment, I can just work my way through my grade book by doing a Ctrl F search for each student's name and see my comments, which reminds me of how they did and assign a grade quickly and easily.
Once I've made my changes to the comments, I check off the "Approved" box and hit, "Update".
I realize that there are ethical considerations involved in changing someone's comments before publishing them, but in my particular case, I think those are outweighed by my ability to publish them quickly, safely and with instant-ish feedback.
Congratulations and thank you to EduBlogs.
(And to Ted Knight and Rodney Dangerfield, wherever you are. You are both greatly missed.)
[Note - I have removed the links to the RootsBlog in this post. I'm in the process of setting up the blog for a new school year and I've erased last year's student posts. I've also temporarily removed the synopses of the episodes from the RootsBlog pages, so that students will be surprised when they see the movies in class. Sorry for any inconvenience.]
One of the most engaging activities each year in my 8th grade Social Studies class is watching the mini-series Roots. Our students are a very, very, VERY white group of kids, living in New Hampshire; for many of them, this is their first prolonged exposure to anything having to do with African-American history or culture. It is very gripping for them.
On the other hand, watching all six episodes takes up 3-4 weeks of classtime over several months. I've been trying to find some way to make watching this movie a less passive experience.
This year, the students are posting to a Roots blog.
After each episode of Roots, the students line up in front of the Awesome Jar of Destiny.
[A note of explanation: the Awesome Jar of Destiny is a technique I use when I'm assigning projects to our 8th graders. I have an empty 1-gallon mayonaise jar with slips of paper in it with all the possible assignments for a particular assignment. The students line up and each draws a slip of paper. They have five minutes or so to compare assignments with each other and trade assignments, if they want to. This adds an element of choice to their project and gives them a little more control over what they do. If a student really, REALLY doesn't like his or her project, he or she can draw a new one from the AJofD, but is then stuck with that project - no redraws, no trading, no nothing. (It's amazing how many students have taken that option this year.) After giving them a few minutes to look at each other's assignments, I have them sit down and I'll call their names from my gradebook, then write down each student's assignment and they are stuck with it. Even the really unmotivated students seem to agree that this is a fair way of doing things.]
For the Roots projects, each slip of paper in the AJofD has the name of one of the characters in the episode the students have just watched. Sometimes it is a minor character, sometimes a major one. In order to have enough characters for each of our 58 students to have his or her own character, some of the major characters are in the jar multiple times. For example: "Kunta Kinte as a boy before going through Manhood Training", "Kunta Kinte after Manhood Training, living in his village in Gambia", "Kunta Kinte after being captured and waiting to be loaded onto the slave ship", ect..
Each student is responsible for writing a short essay (250-1,000 words) about how his or her character felt about the events that went on in the episode, then post that essay to a blog.
After experimenting with a lot of different blogging platforms, I ultimately decided to go with Edublogs. It is not the most user-friendly blogging site around, but in the end, it had the flexibility I needed, without being TOO complicated. I set up seven blogs - one for each episode and one for the project instructions. In each episode blog, there is really only one post - a synopsis of the events of the blog. Each student posts his or her blog entry as a comment under the synopsis. Students can even comment on each other's comments.
All comments are moderated, which means that they get sent to me to check out before I approve them to be posted on the blog.
To protect students' privacy and to practice good internet safety, the students post their comments with their first names and last initials only, as well as the name of the character they are blogging as and the class they are in (to help me with my grading). If a student forgets and puts his or her last name in the blog post, I can catch it as I moderate the comments and edit it before posting it. When I do this, it gets posted under my name, so I put a little explanation at the bottom of the post explaining why it is posted under my name. This gives a pretty good nudge to offending students and they usually are more careful the second time around.
We try very, VERY hard to get parental permission to post student work online. An additional benefit of comment moderation is that for the students for whom we do NOT have permission, I can read their blog post, grade it, then simply not approve it to be posted online.
So far, my students have blogged on two of the six episodes of Roots. The first set of blog entries was a little rocky - which is to be expected for the first attempt at any project - though some individual entries were very good. The second round of blog posts was much, much better. While the spelling and grammar is still not where I'd like it to be, some of these blog posts were heart-breakingly good.
Judge for yourself:
Click here to read the students' instructions.
If you like what you read, please leave a comment to let the students know it. One of our Literacy standards in the 8th grade is writing for a larger audience than just a classroom. Blog comments are a good way for them to know that they are doing that.
The downside of all this is that I'm currently in the middle of showing them Episode Three and I suddenly realize that I don't have any of the little slips of paper written yet.